Image: The Ghost Inside - Official press photo
In our article "Caliban: Fake AI Song Appeared on Spotify!" we already reported that an unknown person uploaded a fake AI song to the Spotify account of Caliban.
However, this does not seem to be an isolated incident, as Caliban is not the only band in the metalcore and hardcore scene to have experienced this. Bands like The Ghost Inside, While She Sleeps, AngelMaker, Bury Tomorrow, and Ghøstkid also had AI-generated songs uploaded without prior notice, at the same time, and sometimes with the same artwork, which rightfully made fans suspicious.
The entire metalcore scene getting tagged on Spotify with the same ai generated instrumental music is wild pic.twitter.com/IlSuFi4t3i
— Mateo Ottie (@MateoOttie) August 26, 2024
Bunch of bands just dropped some new bangers on Spotify pic.twitter.com/HKCzG29vHe
— Justin (@Jarbarino) August 27, 2024
Affected Bands Speak Out
According to Caliban, distributors and streaming platforms are blaming each other, while even major labels seem to be powerless. The solution to this problem certainly requires more attention and concrete measures from all parties involved.
Ghøstkid also addressed the incidents in her Instagram story:
"FYI, because people keep asking about it. Many bands have the same problems with this type of fake releases. Of course, it’s not one of our tracks, and everyone is working on a solution, but it will take some time! Shoutout to the genius who promotes their music by uploading it to other bands' profiles. Ghost, you made my day!"
Joel Holmqvist, frontman of the metalcore band Aviana, also pointed out the system's weaknesses:
"[…] Spotify has some major flaws in verifying whether it is indeed the verified artist who uploaded the song. This person saw a loophole in the system and took full advantage of it. […]"
The Problem Seems To Lie With Spotify
These incidents indicate a systematic problem at Spotify. While it is still unclear where exactly the security gap lies, the fact that this is even possible shows that urgent action is needed.
What Can Be Done?
Of course, labels and managements are striving to resolve the situation. However, this incident clearly shows the problems and dangers posed by AI-generated music. It is important to address this issue directly, consume music consciously, and consistently report fake AI content.
